In the Feb. 18, 2010 episode of Project Runway guest judge Tory Burch said “I’m not sure that blue and orange are that complementary, do you think so?” Heidi, Michael, and Nina (the show’s regular judges) agreed with her.
Maybe Tory meant “I’m not sure that blue and orange are that complimentary, do you think so?”
In either case she – and they – are wrong. And it irks me that fashion designers don’t take the time to understand how colors interact with one another.
Blue and orange are complementary: they visually complete each other. Blue and orange are also complimentary: conveying a compliment, something that is flattering.
I’ve run across so many people that should understand color, but don’t: interior designers, graphic designers, jewelry designers, painters, artists of all mediums. And now, the top fashion designers in the USA.
Color is absolutely critical to these professions — it can make or break a project. Color influences mood, decisions, behavior. It definitely influences how people spend (or don’t spend) money.
It’s shocking to me that these artists do not see the value of learning about color. Why wouldn’t artists want to expand their color knowledge (and possibly their income) to develop their mastery? It’s not hard, and it’s a lot of fun.
Leaving a BeadFest show I shared a shuttle van with another teacher and her assistant. They asked what I did and I told them I taught color. The assistant said “You should see [the teacher in the van]’s work – she’s great with color!” And they opened up many cases of her beadwork. It was all the same three pale colors used in combination. They were lovely combinations, not a thing wrong with them. But over and over the same combinations, the same degree of paleness, the same predictability. (I bet she doesn’t know that humans can see the most subtle shift in color, and can visually distinguish perhaps as many as 10 million colors.)
Years ago, before I’d published my color books, a very well-known bead author said to me “No one will want to spend time learning about color: there’s just not that much to learn. I know what works well together.” (By the way, after 40 years of doing so, I still study color on a regular basis and am still learning.)
I find many artists engaging in two severly limiting behaviors: operating under the the arrogant assumption that they know all there is to know about color, and limiting their work to a couple of combinations they feel safe with. They don’t risk anything. The price is that they don’t gain anything. There’s no personal voice singing through the work, you can see and feel the timidity of playing it safe. It’s mediocre. It’s boring.
As artists on a path of growth we start with the academics: theory and the color wheel. We learn the basics so we know how colors interact optically and impact us emotionally. Then we have the confidence to expand into our own voice, working intuitively and expressively on a solid foundation of learned knowledge. Then comes the magic. Then the mastery. Then the whole cycle all over again, many times, microcosmically and macrocosmically. A never ending, fun-filled journey, rich with rewards.
Congratulations and thank you, Dear Reader. You are not one of the folks blindly unconscious to the value of understanding color. You would not be reading this if you were!
Project Runway Judges: You are welcome to take any of my classes and learn about color with me. I can show you 50 ways to make the complementary colors blue and orange look fantastically complimentary. We did it in my Denver classes.
43 comments
Comments feed for this article
March 4, 2010 at 4:43 pm
Nichole
May I just say- THANK YOU!!! I was screaming at the television when she said that. No one else got it. I only took a few art classes, but loved them. Color theory is Art 101, and complementary/analogous colors are simply illustrated with the color wheel. I hope that the judges have been told since of their quite embarrassing error. They have lost a certain authority to not know something as textbook as a blue and orange complementary pair. Again, thank you so much for this post and your dedication to color!
-Nichole
March 4, 2010 at 4:52 pm
colorforbeadartists
Hi Nichole,
You are SO WELCOME. Like you, my husband and I screamed at the TV set, too – and having been joking about blue and orange “not being complementary” for two weeks.
It was a real disservice to designers, and such a disappointment to see that. I agree about them losing some authority in my eyes.
And its symptomatic of what I see in every artistic field, like I say in my post. I was just shocked to see it at so high a level.
Thank you so much for responding.
Margie
March 4, 2010 at 5:12 pm
Sara Hardin
Both my boyfriend and I were in shock. We thought that it was the best color combination on the show that day!
March 4, 2010 at 5:17 pm
colorforbeadartists
I loved it too, Sara. I especially like how she used brown with it. It was fun, lively, and playful. And definitely complementary. I will use it someday for something.
March 4, 2010 at 5:36 pm
Sarah
Yes! So glad to hear someone else say it!
http://blog.glassbysarah.com/2010/02/24/inspired-by-fashion-or-lack-thereof.aspx
March 4, 2010 at 7:19 pm
colorforbeadartists
Hi Sarah,
I looked at your Feb 24th post from the link you sent – great post! And what fun beads inspired by Amy’s flower petal pants! I am so glad to see someone use these colors – fantastic! Your work is beautiful, Sarah.
http://blog.glassbysarah.com/2010/02/24/inspired-by-fashion-or-lack-thereof.aspx
Margie
March 5, 2010 at 5:40 pm
Sarah
Thank you so much, I’m flattered! 🙂
March 4, 2010 at 6:16 pm
Carol Dean Sharpe
Thank you for this post!
I stopped watching Project Runway some time ago, so I missed this remark…which is a good thing because I too would still be huffing and puffing over it. As a graduate of the University of Texas at El Paso, whose colors happen to be blue and, goodness gracious heaven forbid, orange, I am deeply offended. LOL
How many sycophants are now walking around and labeling all those gorgeous blue and orange creations (including mother nature’s own sunsets) out there as “wrong”? :shudders:
I have a friend who is a painter and a beader. She has only recently made the connection that her understanding of color from painting can directly translate into her beading. Eureka!
March 4, 2010 at 7:14 pm
colorforbeadartists
The Denver Broncos are blue & orange, too! And sunsets… we should banish the blue & orange from sunsets! 🙂
Thanks, Carol.
March 4, 2010 at 7:26 pm
Denise Yezbak Moore
Margie –
I love project Runway. It is one of my favorite shows. I could not believe the fashion industry experts comment about the colors not being complimentary! I thought the pants would look better as a skirt. But I really liked the colors.
I bought your book “The Beader’s Guide To Color” and have been studying it. Although I am a published designer, I believe my weak point is my fear of color. If I could make everything in green or brown I would! I have been pushing myself to buy vibrant color beads to mix, match and play with. I want to thank you for writing this fabulous book! Maybe you should send Heidi, Michael and Nina a copy of your book autographed!!!
March 4, 2010 at 7:44 pm
colorforbeadartists
Denise, Thanks for your enthusiasm about color and my book. Check out the link above by Sarah – she made beads inspired by Amy’s pants on Project Runway and they are beautiful.
Like you wrote, fear of anything is a weak point, that’s human (you should see me quake every time I have to learn a new computer app with a 3″ manual). What irks me is when people are not conscious of their fears and weaknesses and cover it over with arrogance, innaccuracies or dogmatism.
March 4, 2010 at 8:00 pm
Sara Hardin
Sarah’s beads are awesome. Those colors are fab together. These colors together remind me of my good friend and co-worker Jamie Hogsett. She has impeccable taste and isn’t afraid to pair colors together that aren’t totally obvious. I have no idea what the judges were talking about.
March 4, 2010 at 11:26 pm
colorforbeadartists
Jamie’s sense of color is wonderful. She made a gorgeous piece for my latest Color report for bead & Jewelry Artists… but you already know that!
March 4, 2010 at 10:48 pm
Denise Yezbak Moore
Sarah did a great job using the Project Runway outfit as inspiration. The beads are beautiful! Let us know if you decide to send them each a book! On a another note….. are you Lebanese? (Yezbak is Lebanese).
March 4, 2010 at 11:28 pm
colorforbeadartists
Hi Denise, My last name is middle Eastern, from Syria. My father was adopted into a Syrian family. I understand it is a popular Sudanese and Lebanese name, as well. “Yezbak” is fun to say!
March 5, 2010 at 12:31 am
Erin Prais-Hintz
Brava! I too was flabbergasted when I heard that comment from the judges. They absolutely could do well with taking your class. Maybe you should send them a signed copy of your book and an invitation!
As a designer I know that I peg my favorite works in a certain color spectrum. I took an oil painting class in December, and the best thing we did was work with the color wheel. We created it on canvas boards and then worked to fill the entire thing with all the variations of the color spectrum. I have mine behind my computer to remind me that my goal this year is to live in color, to design more in bright colors, or schemes I wouldn’t normally try. I have even used this as an interesting backdrop for photographing my work, on the complementary color section, of course!
I am excited about the ABS color challenge. Coincidentally, a piece that I am working on for a client had those same colors in it, so that makes it easier for me to create, when I know the woman who will wear it.
Thank you for your inspiration today!
Enjoy the day!
Erin
March 5, 2010 at 11:16 am
colorforbeadartists
Thank you, Erin.
Making color wheels is such a great exercise. I love doing it in all kinds of mediums. It recalibrates my eyes!
March 5, 2010 at 6:18 am
Kathy Vorenberg
Bravo, Margie! I certainly hope you find a way to let these Project Runway folks know about their goof-up. When I taught quilting classes many, many years ago, the single biggest problem I encountered was the fear of using color “outside the box” of ordinary thought.
I am so delighted to experiment with color in my beadwork and I love your book — it is always within reach on my worktable.
March 5, 2010 at 11:17 am
colorforbeadartists
I’m so glad you love my book, whichever one you are referring to! Thanks for responding, Kathy!
March 5, 2010 at 4:23 pm
Carole Carlson
I saw the Project Runway episode last night (my daughter had recorded it), and I just about flipped when they made that remark. Like Denise, I thought the outfit would have been better as a skirt, rather than as pants, but to say that the colors didn’t go together was just silly. The judges saw “clown”, I saw “fun”.
March 5, 2010 at 6:43 pm
colorforbeadartists
I didn’t mind the colors or the design too much either Carole. But I am fine with them hating it – its taste and I won’t debate something so subjective. I’m appalled that designers in such prominent position don’t know color. And I don’t understand it. Thanks for responding.
March 7, 2010 at 3:37 pm
Mortira
I love watching Project Runway because it’s fun to see the designers interpret each week’s inspirations. I almost never agree with the judges though, and I’m almost glad I didn’t see this episode. I’ll have to see if I can track it down to see what the blue and orange piece looked like. I bet it was gorgeous!
March 8, 2010 at 10:06 am
colorforbeadartists
Hi Mortira,
http://open.salon.com/blog/cherylanneny/2010/02/18/project_runway_week_6_kiddie_couture
Try the above link and scroll down – you’ll see Amy’s blue & orange concoction.
Thanks for responding!
Margie
March 9, 2010 at 4:22 pm
Mortira
Ah, thank you for that link! I had a feeling the piece in question would be stunning, and I think that it is. Perhaps it would have looked better as a skirt instead of pants, but the colors are wonderful, and the shape of the ‘petals’ really fit the palette. I’m sure Amy won’t have any trouble finding work when the show is finished.
March 10, 2010 at 6:02 am
Belinda Saville
Brilliant! The passion in your words is obvious, and you have stirred a passion within me also. If only there were more advocates for colour, like you, Margie!
My latest beadwoven creation (inspired by your bold use of colour!) uses only blue and orange beads (I hope it is ok to post the link here…if not, please delete!):
http://beadfetish.blogspot.com/2010/03/cerulean-sunset.html
I was amazed by the number of people who, upon seeing this piece, told me how much they love the blue/orange combination…and yet I have never seen any of them produce work with these colours!
Why are people so afraid of colour? It adds dimension, individuality and stimulation…but we tend to stick with colours we know, combinations which are safe. How boring!
There is no excuse for industry professionals, who work with colour on a daily basis, to not have an in-depth knowledge and understanding of colour. I no longer have cable tv, so I don’t watch Project Runway anymore…but it saddens me to hear that the judges are so ignorant in their knowledge of colour. Sure, they don’t have to like the colours. But show a little respect for colour, please!
Ok, I’ll hop down off my soap box now 😉
Thanks for being an inspiration…my copy of “The Beaders Guide to Color” is always within arm’s reach 🙂
March 10, 2010 at 1:24 pm
colorforbeadartists
Hi Brenda – thanks for calling me an “advocate for colour”.. I am. I feel the need to champion it when people make negligent, unfounded remarks.
Your piece (thank you for posting the link here!) is PURE blue and orange… how very brave of you! Its really fun! And it works!
I think people are afraid of color for many reasons. The two I find most prevalent in my classes is the amount of choices and lack of knowledge. Put those two reasons together and you have a formula for fear of anything. It makes sense… that’s why I teach. Everyone leaves my color class with little to know fear after a bi of knowledge, and the permission to listen to their intuition.
As for Project Runway judges – I totally agree with you “show a little respect for color” ! LOL!
Thank you for your fun post – I’m on the soapbox with you.
March 9, 2010 at 4:27 pm
Mikki
I don’t think I screamed at the TV……..I believe I rolled my eyes and sighed. Sometimes, those judges……
I think anyone who believes they know everything about a subject needs to watch the try-outs for American Idol….lots of people there who think they know everything about singing. My feeling is that if you ever get to feel you know everything there is to know about a subject look down very quickly, you just might miss that sink hole.
March 10, 2010 at 10:58 am
colorforbeadartists
Mikki wrote “I think anyone who believes they know everything about a subject needs to watch the try-outs for American Idol”. THAT IS SO FUNNY and so true! Great post, Mikki, thanks!
March 9, 2010 at 4:32 pm
Jennifer Cameron
I’ve never watched that show before, but thoroughly enjoyed your post. I admit I am not a huge fan of blue and orange together (it makes me think of sports team jersey colors) but know they complement each other and appreciate them in nature or as a small pop of color. In fact, when I was trying to select a glass color for pendant lights above a bar in our “pumpkin spice” colored family room, I selected blue for that very reason.
Shhh….don’t tell anyone, but I don’t love red and green together because it makes me think of Christmas. But it’s beautiful in nature and I used red throw pillows in a green room.
March 10, 2010 at 11:00 am
colorforbeadartists
Hi Jennifer… i don’t know anyone that likes pure red and pure green together. The trick is to vary the shades, tints, tones, value, and intensity of each of those 2 complementary colors until you come up with combinations that appeal to you. I am crazy over brilliant fuchsia and chartreuse, a derivative of the red/green combo.
I imagine the blue lights above your bar look great!
-Margie
March 9, 2010 at 6:19 pm
shirley tyderkie
Margie: Ihave been learning about color as long as I can remember, since my teens. Your books follow my thinking, and I have told you before they are wonderful. I will never stop trying to learn about color, which is so important to the impact of what you are creating. I don’t feel I have learned it all yet, and I am now 80. The idea of some of the comments of some of the judges makes me cringe, over the years I have been in many shoes, and one does sometimes have to be very forceful to be convincing. Please continue to teach me. I will never stop.
March 10, 2010 at 11:16 am
colorforbeadartists
Thank you so much, Shirley. I love your spirit!
-Margie
March 10, 2010 at 2:22 am
Sue
I don’t watch the show, but I agree with Margie that the only way the comment makes any sense is that the designer meant “complimentary” as in “flattering.” At least that would be an understandable, if disputable, statement.
As a completely self-taught beader, I’d be lost without your latest book and colour forecasts, Margie. I was devastated to discover that I’d missed your Toronto visit recently. “Color for Bead Artists” is endlessly inspiring. Left on my own, all my designs would be in your Baroque palette, lol!
March 10, 2010 at 11:18 am
colorforbeadartists
Hi Sue, I’m sorry you missed my Toronto visit, too! I’d love to see all of your baroque palettes!
Thanks for responding… I hope I will make it back to Toronto soon.
-Margie
March 10, 2010 at 11:34 am
Meredith
It certainly is disturbing when people in a position where they exert some authority are so obviously ignorant. However, when I looked the word ‘complimentary’ up in my online American Heritage Dictionary this is what it said:
complimentary |ˌkämpləˈmentərē; -ˈmentrē|
adjective
1 expressing a compliment; praising or approving : Jennie was very complimentary about Kathy’s riding | complimentary remarks.
2 given or supplied free of charge : a complimentary bottle of wine.
no where was its use in color terminology mentioned! Odd—and a possible reason for such ignorance. — Anyway, I have all your books and enjoy them tremendously. Now the area where I come up short is not in color combinations so much as proportion, distribution, and the use of neutrals, to give one’s eye a resting place. Often I think gold, silver, copper, bronze, etc. are the beaders neutrals—and then there is the whole issue of matte beads, crystals, AB finishes, sizes, and on and on endlessly. Thanks for a such a fun blog. I don’t read too many of these, being an old lady, but this is really great.
My fashion pet peeve is the Kurt Cobain legacy, the whole ‘grunge’ look…dirty colors, mismatched and extremely distressed.
March 10, 2010 at 1:34 pm
colorforbeadartists
Hi Meredith,
There are 2 spellings of the word “complementary” and I use both in the first few paragraphs of my post. I consider the judges use of either definition wrong (as I said in my post). Using the word “complimentary” is a bit more subjective, but of course blue and orange do flatter one another because they are complementary.
I am in agreement with your fashion pet peeve, too! It does nothing for me!
Proportions are critical to color use, and I plan on several publications and classes for that alone. You can have gorgeous colors, but they won’t spectacular unless they are used in a spectacular proportions – so it is no wonder this is a difficult area for you or anyone.
Thank you for your compliment on my blog – I want it to be valuable and inspirational and fun to readers!
March 10, 2010 at 4:39 pm
Meredith
Well, gee Margie…I guess my ignorance is showing as well. I never noticed there were two choices. Thanks for the English lesson! Spelling has never been one of my strengths LOL!
March 10, 2010 at 11:46 am
colorforbeadartists
I wrote to Leatrice Eiseman, a color specialist and prime consultant to Pantone, Inc., because I value her opinion. I wanted to know her thoughts on people in color-dependent careers not understanding color, which is the essence of my issue. Read what Lee wrote to me:
“I couldn’t agree more with your comments about the lack of color education, even from those people we would expect more of! I have consistently told my students (or anyone who cares to listen to my rantings) that there is a difference, for example, between the word “complimentary” (with an “I”) and complementary (with an “e”) and you have stated it very well in your response to the Project Runway faux pas.
What is even more astounding is that Tory Burch would raise the issue of “I don’t think that orange and blue are that complimentary’. First of all, what arbitrary rules is she using? And would that mean in every single usage of pairing orange and blue, she considers they would not be complimentary? It is what I refer to as the “sweeping generality” that you so often hear about color. Who decreed that those two colors do not compliment each other (with an “I”) or do not “look good together”? Especially anyone who has studied the color wheel and does understand, in fact, that orange and blue are complementary (with an e). As you stated so aptly in your blog— they “complete’ each other as they are opposites on the wheel.
Another very important point is: What shade of either of the color families is she referring to? What about terra cotta and turquoise blue? Or peach and periwinkle? Or ultramarine and coral, not to mention any shade of denim blue with any shade of orange? Do they not both complement and compliment?
Lastly, after many years of teaching, consulting, researching, forecasting and writing books on color, I am the last person to say that artists and designers should not use their own “instincts” in putting colors together. But we all need to continue our color education, to open ourselves to learning more that might provide an impetus —a “jumpstart’ to inspiring new or interesting or intriguing ways of combining colors.”
Lee’s books and work have been an inspiration to me for many years. I love her approach to color and her humor and spirit. You can learn more about her work here:
http://www.colorexpert.com
http://www.morealivewithcolor.com
March 12, 2010 at 10:44 pm
Gabriela
Hello. My name is Gabriela and I just want to say thank you for pointing this out. I have been beading as a hobby for the last six years and I thought the outfit on Project Runway was a good use of colors that designers don’t take into consideration. I love the color scheme and it took guts for a designer to break away from the traditional looks and colors of fashion. I am not a fashion trend setter but I do know what colors would compliment my skin tone and which ones would not.
March 12, 2010 at 11:56 pm
colorforbeadartists
Thank you, Gabriela. I appreciate hearing from you – and I think it took courage for Amy to use those colors on Project Runway, too.
March 14, 2010 at 9:18 am
Chris Murphy
I didn’t see the episode but I could not agree more. Reading your book has stretched my ideas of color and I am experimenting with your artbead challenge of color. I am more aware of color now when beading thanks to you and it is my hope to take one of your classes someday.
March 15, 2010 at 9:20 am
colorforbeadartists
Thanks, Chris! Though I’m not judging the Artbeads color challenge, I look forward to seeing your entry!
March 14, 2010 at 11:34 am
Sunday Brunch: Week 11 « Wild Vanilla Designs
[…] 1. Color for Bead Artists Project Runway Judges: Do You Know Color? […]